Sentencing is a nuanced process, not a straightforward calculation. When a person is found guilty or pleads guilty, the judge must determine the appropriate sentence. Judges have substantial discretion, guided by legal constraints and precedents. Several crucial factors influence this decision:

• Severity of the Offense: Judges assess the gravity of the crime committed.
• Offender’s Responsibility: The level of the offender’s involvement in the offense is considered.
• Community Denouncement: Judges contemplate if the offense contradicts community values.
• Deterrence and Prevention: Sentences may deter both the offender and others from similar offenses.
• Social Reintegration and Rehabilitation: Judges weigh the potential for the offender’s rehabilitation.
• Restitution and Acknowledgment: Sentences may address harm done to victims and the community.
• Offender’s Personal Circumstances: Factors like age, background, and motives are taken into account.
• Criminal History: Past offenses influence the judge’s decision.
• Judicial Discretion and Precedents: Judges reference prior cases and legal principles while maintaining flexibility.

Common Sentencing Options: A Range of Choices

• Jail Sentences and Intermittent Jail Sentences: Offenders may serve time in provincial or federal facilities, with options like intermittent sentences for short jail terms.
• Conditional Sentences and House Arrest: Conditional Sentence Orders (CSO) allow some offenders to serve their sentence in the community under strict conditions.
• Fines: Judges may impose fines based on the offense, with jail time as an alternative for non-payment.
• Probation and Suspended Sentences: Probation includes conditions like counseling or community service, while suspended sentences involve probation without formal conviction.
• Conditional Discharges and Absolute Discharges: Conditional discharges involve probation, eventually removed from the criminal record. Absolute discharges result in no punishment but stay on record for a year.

Post-Sentencing Orders: Additional Measures

• DNA Sample Orders: Certain offenders must provide DNA samples for the national database.
• Firearms and Weapons Prohibitions: Offenders may face restrictions on possessing weapons based on the nature of the offense.
• Sex Offenders Information Registry (SOIRA) Orders: Sex offenders must register and report personal information for a specific period, with options for termination after a waiting period.
• Restitution Orders: Offenders might be required to compensate victims for stolen or damaged property.
• Victim Fine Surcharges: A surcharge is imposed on offenders, contributing to victim support services.

In the complex world of sentencing, judges balance legal frameworks, precedents, and individual circumstances, striving for fairness and justice in each case.

The post Sentencing & Sentencing Options appeared first on LAW FIRM.

In Canada, your right to remain silent is constitutionally protected and enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Generally, you are not obligated to provide any information to the police, but there are exceptions to this rule.

Exceptions to the Rule: When You Must Provide Information

• Upon Arrest: You are required to provide your name, address, and date of birth to the police.
• Motor Vehicle Incidents: If you are involved in a motor vehicle accident, you must complete a collision statement as per the Traffic Safety Act.
• Regulated Activities: Certain regulated activities may necessitate providing information to investigators or regulators.

Consult a Lawyer: Your Best Course of Action

If you are uncertain about your obligations, always consult with a lawyer. They can guide you on what information you must provide and what you can withhold, ensuring your rights are protected.

Can You Lie to the Police?

No, you cannot lie to the police. Lying to a police officer may constitute serious criminal offenses such as “obstructing a peace officer” or “obstruction of justice.”

Police Interaction: Meeting with the Police

If the police want to meet with you, there is a possibility they may arrest you. It’s crucial to consult with a lawyer before meeting them. You have the right to legal counsel before answering any questions or providing a statement.

Providing a Statement: Risks and Precautions

Even if you are innocent, speaking with the police carries risks. Your words might be used against you, and there could be legal consequences even if you believe you are completely innocent. Consulting a lawyer before speaking with the police is essential to safeguard your rights.

Speaking “Off the Record”: A Common Misconception

There is no concept of speaking “off the record” with a police officer. Anything you say, whether written or verbal, can be used against you in court.

Seeking Legal Counsel: Your Right, Not an Admission of Guilt

Speaking with a lawyer does not imply guilt. Both innocent and guilty individuals need legal advice. It is a fundamental right aimed at protecting your interests and ensuring you make informed decisions.

Who to Contact for Guidance?

If you have questions or concerns, reach out to a lawyer at Smyllie Law for expert advice before interacting with the police. Protect your rights and make informed choices with professional legal guidance.

The post What You Need to Know if the Police Want to Speak with You appeared first on LAW FIRM.

Bail, or judicial interim release, is the process of releasing an accused person before their trial or resolution of charges. The rules and procedures for bail are outlined in the Criminal Code, influenced by common law and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Bail Hearing Process:

When arrested for a criminal offence, the accused must be brought before a justice of the peace within 24 hours. A bail hearing is conducted either over the phone or in court. The justice determines whether the accused will be granted bail or held in custody.

Possible Outcomes of a Bail Hearing:

• Undertaking to attend court without conditions
• Undertaking to attend court with specific conditions
• Recognizance with conditions, possibly requiring cash deposit or sureties
• Bail denied, leading to the accused remaining in custody

Grounds for Bail Denial:

Bail can be denied based on:

• Primary Grounds: Ensuring the accused’s court attendance, considering community ties and prior convictions for non-attendance.
• Secondary Grounds: Ensuring public safety, assessing the likelihood of further criminal activity or interference with justice based on criminal record.
• Tertiary Grounds: Maintaining confidence in justice administration, evaluating case strength, offence gravity, and potential sentence length.

Imposing Conditions:

Conditions may be imposed to address concerns about the accused’s release, such as geographical restrictions, curfews, or non-communication orders. Justices have discretion but must be reasonable.

Changing Bail Conditions:

Conditions can be changed with consent from the Crown Prosecutor or through a bail review in Court King’s Bench, where arguments are presented for or against altering conditions.

Recognizance: A Legal Promise

A recognizance is a promise to pay the Crown if the accused breaches bail conditions. It can be cash-based or without a deposit, depending on the case’s circumstances.

Role of a Surety:

A surety supervises the accused, ensuring court attendance and compliance with conditions. They can be a close adult, but certain individuals, like accomplices or those with criminal records, are usually not allowed.

Withdrawing as a Surety:

A surety can withdraw in writing, leading to the accused’s arrest, or by bringing the accused to court. Substituting another surety follows a similar procedure.

Surety’s Financial Obligation:

A surety enters a debt with the Crown through a recognizance, indicating their commitment. A cash deposit may be required, refundable upon successful completion of the accused’s legal matters.

The post How Does Bail Work? appeared first on LAW FIRM.

When facing criminal charges, the looming question often is, “Will I go to jail?” It’s crucial to note that being accused doesn’t mean an automatic jail term; one is presumed innocent until proven guilty. The severity of a sentence depends on various factors, assessed by the judge. Here’s a breakdown:

Factors Related to the Offence:

• Nature of the Offence: More serious crimes are more likely to lead to imprisonment. For instance, stealing from a store might not result in jail, but pulling a weapon during the theft likely will.
• Aggravating Circumstances: Certain factors increase the likelihood of jail, such as hate motivation, abuse of trust, terrorism involvement, deliberate planning, or greed-driven motives.

Factors Related to the Offender:

• Age and Character: Young age or a crime out of character might mitigate the sentence. A strong character, community contributions, and family support can be mitigating factors.
• Addiction/Mental Health and Remorse: If the offence stemmed from addiction or mental health issues, seeking treatment can be mitigating. Remorse, demonstrated through accepting responsibility or cooperation, also plays a crucial role.

Impact of Criminal Record:

• Record Severity: A lengthy or severe criminal record increases the likelihood of imprisonment, especially for similar offences.
• Record Age: An older record implies rehabilitation and may lessen its impact on sentencing.

Mandatory Minimum Sentences:

Certain offences mandate minimum imprisonment, especially in cases involving firearms, sexual crimes, drug offences, or repeated convictions (e.g., DUI).

Pre-trial Custody:

Time served before trial can count towards the sentence but doesn’t negate the need for an official sentence. It merely reduces post-conviction jail time.

Non-Criminal Offences:

For regulatory offences, imprisonment rarely exceeds six months, except in specific cases like unauthorized driving, which carries a 14-day mandatory minimum sentence.

Examples:

• Minor Theft: Unlikely for jail, especially with no criminal record and sympathetic circumstances.
• Embezzlement from Trust: Likely jail due to breach of trust and victims being children, despite remorse and lack of prior record.
• Mischief (Property Damage): Unlikely for jail with an old record and minor offence.
• Assault (Repeated Offence): Likely jail due to the third conviction, even if the incident was minor.
• DUI (Repeat Offence): Mandatory minimum sentence likely due to the previous conviction, despite remorse.
• Child Luring: Mandatory minimum jail sentence due to the nature of the offence.

Seek Legal Counsel:

For any criminal charge, consulting a defense lawyer is crucial. While jail risk is a concern, experienced lawyers can navigate the complexities, potentially mitigating or avoiding imprisonment. Smyllie Law offers expert legal advice, ensuring the best possible outcome for your case.

The post Am I Going to Go to Jail? appeared first on LAW FIRM.

In Canada, a criminal record includes information about all criminal convictions and sentences, including fingerprints and DNA, stored in a database maintained by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police. Such records can have significant long-term consequences on employability and international travel. However, individuals convicted of criminal offenses can apply for a record suspension, previously known as “pardons,” through the Parole Board of Canada.

Eligibility and Waiting Periods:

To apply for a record suspension, the sentence for the conviction must have concluded. There’s a ten-year waiting period for indictable offenses and a five-year waiting period for summary conviction offenses after the completion of the sentence. For instance, someone convicted of theft under $5000 in 2015 becomes eligible for a suspension five years after paying the fine in full.

Application Process and Costs:

Applying for a record suspension costs $631, and it involves applying to have specific convictions suspended. A record suspension doesn’t erase the record but moves it to a separate database. The Minister of Public Safety must approve any disclosure of suspended records, except in exceptional circumstances related to justice administration, safety, security, or identifying a deceased person.

Discharges and Fingerprints/DNA:

Individuals discharged instead of convicted do not need to apply for a suspension. Discharge records are automatically removed from the RCMP database after one or three years, depending on the type of discharge. However, fingerprints taken during arrest will remain, even with a record suspension, though they may be removed from local databases.

Ineligible Offenses and Suspension Approval:

Certain offenses, primarily sexual offenses involving young victims, are ineligible for record suspension. Approval for a record suspension depends on good conduct, the potential benefit to the individual’s rehabilitation, and not bringing the administration of justice into disrepute. If an application is refused, the applicant can reapply after a year.

Revocation of Record Suspension and Legal Assistance:

Record suspensions can be revoked under specific circumstances, such as new convictions or deceptive statements in the application. While requesting a record suspension is generally a straightforward process, individuals can seek legal advice for specific concerns regarding their criminal record suspensions. The Government of Canada provides comprehensive resources to guide applicants through the process.

The post Criminal Record Suspensions appeared first on LAW FIRM.

Solicitor-client privilege safeguards confidential communications between a lawyer and a client, essential for seeking, forming, or giving legal advice. This article delves into the nuances of this privilege, emphasizing its significance and limitations.

Purpose and Significance:

Society highly values solicitor-client privilege, fostering open discussions crucial for ethical legal decisions. Clients must speak freely, ensuring lawyers receive a complete picture for providing effective advice. This privilege promotes full disclosure and protects the client’s interests.

Protected Communications:

Communications with a lawyer, whether in person, over the phone, via voicemail, email, or text, remain confidential. Even interactions with legal assistants or other firm members are privileged. Disclosure to family or friends requires client consent, maintaining confidentiality.

Permanence of Privilege:

Solicitor-client privilege endures even after the relationship ends and the case concludes. It survives the client’s death, except in specific cases such as contested wills.

Involvement of Third Parties:

Confidentiality requires communication intent. Involving trusted third parties, like family or friends, is allowed if they share a joint interest. However, clients must trust these individuals to maintain confidentiality. Lawyers may limit involvement based on case specifics.

Limits and Exceptions:

• Protects legal advice exclusively, excluding non-legal discussions.
• Agents acting on behalf of the lawyer, like experts, enjoy privilege extension.
• Protects communications, not pure facts or physical objects.
• No privilege for present or future criminal activities; exceptions apply for advice on legal behavior.
• Public safety concerns can override privilege in imminent harm scenarios.

Waiver and Consent:

Solicitor-client privilege belongs to the client and can only be waived with their explicit, informed consent. Clear, voluntary waivers are required, either express or implied based on fairness and consistency.

Importance of Hiring a Lawyer:

When facing criminal charges, hiring a lawyer is vital to safeguarding one’s future. Smyllie Law offers expert legal advice, ensuring privileged conversations remain confidential throughout the legal process.

The post What is Solicitor-Client Privilege? appeared first on LAW FIRM.

Ensure you file your appeal within 30 days of being convicted or found guilty. Failure to meet this deadline might jeopardize your chance to appeal. Consult a lawyer at Smyllie Law immediately after the decision to understand the necessary steps.

Why You Need Legal Representation?

Appeals are intricate processes governed by strict rules and deadlines. Attempting to handle your appeal on your own can have severe consequences. It’s strongly advised to consult one of our experienced lawyers at Smyllie Law to navigate the complexities of your case effectively.

Determining the Appropriate Court:

The court to which you appeal depends on whether your trial was conducted in the Court King’s Bench or the Provincial Court, and whether proceedings were conducted “summarily” or “by indictment.” Seek clarification from court clerks or your legal representatives to determine the correct appellate jurisdiction.

Grounds for Appeal: Errors of Law and Mistakes of Fact

Appeals generally revolve around errors of law (incorrect legal decisions) or mistakes of fact (getting the facts wrong or deciding what to believe). Understanding these distinctions is crucial, as they impact the review process and the likelihood of a successful appeal.

What to Expect During an Appeal?

An appeal is not a retrial but a review of the existing trial record. This includes transcripts and exhibits. Written legal arguments are submitted, followed by oral hearings where arguments are presented. The decision-making process might take several months before a ruling is delivered.

Potential Outcomes: New Trial or Acquittal

Winning an appeal often leads to a new trial in the same court. In rare instances, an appeal court might find you not guilty, especially if crucial evidence was wrongly admitted, significantly impacting the case against you.

Hiring an Appeal Lawyer: Your Key to Success

If you’re considering an appeal, it’s crucial to consult a lawyer immediately. Smyllie Law’s experienced lawyers specialize in conducting appeals and providing expert advice. Contact our office today for a free consultation to discuss your case in detail.

The post Can I Appeal a Criminal Conviction? appeared first on LAW FIRM.

If you’ve been found guilty and sentenced by a judge or justice, but you don’t agree with the sentence, there are steps you can take to appeal the decision.

Contact a Lawyer Immediately:

The Criminal Code allows you to request a review of the judge or justice’s sentencing decision. It’s crucial to consult with a lawyer promptly to initiate the appeal process. Delays can jeopardize your ability to appeal.

Act Within 30 Days:

You must file your notice of appeal within 30 days of being sentenced. Failing to do so may result in the loss of your right to appeal. This timeline is critical.

Consult with a Lawyer Right Away:

Consulting with a lawyer immediately after the sentencing decision is essential. There are specific steps that need to be taken, and your lawyer can guide you through them.

Should You Handle Your Own Appeal?

While it’s possible to handle your own appeal, it’s not recommended. Appeals are complex, with strict deadlines and rules. Mistakes can have severe consequences, potentially leading to the disallowance of your appeal without a chance to argue for a different sentence.

Determine Where to Appeal:

The court where you appeal depends on where your sentencing took place. If it was in the Court of King’s Bench, your appeal will be heard in the Court of Appeal. For Provincial Court cases, it depends on whether it was conducted “summarily” or “by indictment.”

Grounds for Appeal:

You can appeal the type of sentence, its length, or imposed conditions. Generally, the reviewing court examines if the initial judge or justice was obviously wrong or unreasonable in their decision.

The Appeal Process:

An appeal does not involve redoing the original trial. It reviews the existing record, including trial transcripts and exhibits. Both you and the Crown Prosecutor submit written legal arguments, followed by oral arguments during a hearing. The appeal justices will consider these arguments before making a decision, which can take several months.

Winning the Appeal:

If you win your appeal, the Appeal Court will often conduct a re-sentencing, potentially leading to a different sentence type, length, or altered conditions. In rare cases, your sentence may be set aside for a complete re-sentencing.

Hiring an Appeal Lawyer:

If you’re considering an appeal, it’s crucial to engage a lawyer with experience in appeals. At Smyllie Law, our lawyers are renowned for their expertise in appeals and can provide expert guidance. Contact our office for a free consultation.

The post Can I Appeal a Sentence? appeared first on LAW FIRM.

If you find yourself disagreeing with a traffic or regulatory offence verdict, swift action is crucial. The justice system allows a 30-day window post the case conclusion for filing an appeal. Delaying beyond this limit might permanently bar you from the appeals process.

Consultation with Legal Experts: Immediate Guidance Matters

Consulting with legal professionals immediately after your trial conclusion is imperative. Experienced lawyers can guide you through the necessary steps, ensuring you meet crucial deadlines and fulfill legal requirements.

Understanding the Complexity: Why DIY Appeals Are Not Advisable

While it’s technically possible to handle your own appeal, it’s highly discouraged. Appeals involve intricate rules, specific deadlines, and a thorough understanding of legal proceedings. Missing a deadline or misunderstanding the rules can lead to severe consequences, including the dismissal of your appeal without a chance to present your case.

Appeal Venue: Court of King’s Bench

For provincial offences, including traffic matters, appeals are processed in the Court of King’s Bench.

Grounds for Appeal: Various Aspects to Challenge

Appeals can arise from diverse situations, such as convictions in absence or guilty verdicts after a trial. You can appeal the trial process, decisions made by the judge, or unreasonable findings of fact. Additionally, you have the right to appeal the imposed sentence.

Appeal Procedure: A Review of Existing Records

An appeal doesn’t entail a complete trial redo. Instead, it involves reviewing existing records, including trial transcripts and exhibits. These records are examined for potential judicial errors or issues with the conduct of your defense. Subsequently, written legal arguments are submitted to the appeal justice or justices.

Oral Hearing and Decision Process: Detailed Examination

During the oral hearing, your lawyer presents arguments primarily focusing on potential mistakes made by the judge that influenced their decisions. There’s a back-and-forth discussion with the appeal justice or justices, followed by the Crown Prosecutor’s arguments. After the presentations, a decision-making process begins, which might take several months before a verdict is reached.

Outcome of a Successful Appeal: What to Expect

The outcome varies based on your appeal grounds. If your appeal succeeds, the consequences differ. For instance, if you appeal a conviction, you might receive a new trial. If it’s about your sentence, a re-sentencing occurs, possibly leading to different sentencing terms or conditions.

Professional Support: Importance of Hiring an Appeal Lawyer

Considering an appeal? Don’t hesitate to seek legal assistance promptly. Experienced appeal lawyers, like those at Smyllie Law, provide expert advice and guide you through the process. Schedule a free consultation with our office today.

The post Can I Appeal My Decision in Traffic Court? appeared first on LAW FIRM.

In Canadian law, individuals can be charged with attempting to commit a criminal offense even if the actual crime was not successfully executed. This article delves into the circumstances under which a person can face charges for attempted offenses and outlines the crucial elements the Crown must prove during trial. It is essential to note that the legal terrain in this area can be intricate. If you find yourself charged with attempting to commit an offense, seeking advice from a lawyer is imperative. Smyllie Law offers free consultations to discuss your case.

Understanding the Three Key Elements of an Attempted Offense:

To establish an attempted offense, three fundamental elements must be present:

• Intention to Commit the Offense: The prosecution must prove that the accused had the specific intention required to commit the crime at the time of the attempt. This involves considering the actions, behavior, and statements of the accused, both before and during the alleged attempt.
• Steps Taken Towards Committing the Crime: The prosecution must demonstrate that the accused undertook real actions or omissions, moving beyond mere preparation, to commit the offense. Whether these actions constitute an attempt is determined by their proximity to the actual commission of the crime.
• Non-Commission of the Offense: The accused must have been unsuccessful in executing the offense. If the crime had been completed, the individual would be charged with the completed offense, not an attempt.

Illustrative Examples and Legal Analysis:

To illustrate, consider a scenario where an individual attempts to steal from a safe but is thwarted by circumstances. Even if the safe turns out to be empty, the attempt charge stands, provided the intention and significant steps towards theft are proven.

Attempted Assault: A Specific Case

Assault, defined in the Criminal Code, includes attempts or threats to apply force to another person, even without physical contact. For instance, brandishing a weapon with the intent to harm constitutes an assault, regardless of whether contact occurs.

Seeking Legal Representation: Your Path Forward

Navigating attempted crimes within the Canadian legal framework can be intricate, especially concerning serious offenses. Attempt charges can be associated with various Criminal Code offenses, necessitating a careful examination of the case’s unique circumstances and expert legal advice. If you are facing charges for attempting to commit a crime, the experienced lawyers at Smyllie Law are available for a free consultation to help you understand your options and guide you through the legal process.

The post Can I Be Charged With Attempting to Commit a Crime? appeared first on LAW FIRM.